Tend to whenever times are offered, they are provided with 1 day of your own week one to do not fits with this date as it from inside the genuine records. One particular analogy occurs in Harry Potter while the Prisoner from Azkaban when Sybill Trelawney makes reference to sixteen October since Friday, though 16 October 1993 is a tuesday.
There are also contradictions within the guides in this field. Particularly, into the Harry Potter plus the Goblet regarding Flame, sexy Santa cruz de la sierra girl each other 1 Sep and 2 September are supplied since Mondays and, in Harry Potter additionally the Prisoner out of Azkaban, Buckbeak’s demonstration is set to your 20 April, but cautious parsing of your text suggests that it could keeps happened no afterwards than just March.
Plus, inside Harry Potter in addition to Goblet regarding Flames they state that the Winners had been chosen on Monday 30 Oct, but 29 Oct try a tuesday inside the 1994.
In the chapter 7 away from Quidditch From the Many years, they do say your first Quidditch Community Mug occured in 1473. In the event your tournament is held most of the four years, it disputes toward statement into the Cup away from Fire that 1994 Business Cup was new 422nd. In the event that Quidditch Through the Decades is useful, the latest 422nd Quidditch Community Glass create in reality fall-in the season 3161, however if Cup from Fire is great, the original Community Mug had been held within the 306.
Historic troubles [ ]
Although the series, with regards to the schedule derived from the newest Chamber out of Gifts site, is set regarding the nineties, brand new collection commonly appears like it’s invest new later nineties so you can middle-2000s, approximately concurrent on publication of one’s instructions. Within the Harry Potter together with 1 / 2 of-Bloodstream Prince, Cornelius Fudge spends a male pronoun to refer for the „predecessor“ of Perfect Minister of the British. According to more than schedule, this would occur in summer time out-of 1996, in the event that Perfect Minister was John Big, whoever instant predecessor try a lady (is why basic ending up in Fudge, the publication says the fresh election, but Biggest was not very first elected and simply took over immediately following Thatcher retired.
You will be able, not unrealistic, you to definitely Fudge was writing on a more faraway ancestor, due to the fact Thatcher took office ahead of Fudge supposedly turned Minister to possess Wonders. (Regardless if you can think a situation in which Fudge is actually delegated from the Minister to own Magic to satisfy into the Perfect Minister as he, Fudge, was a student in a smaller work environment.) At the same time, the fresh new identity and you may history of the top Minister illustrated generally seems to alot more closely fits that of Tony Blair than just from John Big. A post regarding Day-after-day Send notes one Rowling is actually close with the up coming-Chancellor of your own Exchequer Gordon Brownish (commonly considered a rival to Blair’s frontrunners of one’s Labor People, which succeeded your and you may turned into Perfect Minister), which she could have been trying to let you know Blair’s worst side. In case the instructions was invest sync having book date regarding Philosopher’s Brick, up coming this enjoy perform occur in 2002 (immediately after Blair turned Prime Minister).
But not, it actually was afterwards stated that 22 November are a tuesday, which it was at 1994
A comparable situation involves Nicolas Flamel, who was said as being 665 during the time of the latest basic book, but Nicolas Flamel was a bona fide historical shape and would not reach that many years until 1996, within date the first guide is blogged. This new rebuttal for it is the fact that the go out the new „real“ Nicolas Flamel was created cannot talk to new Nicolas Flamel of Harry Potter.
A separate state is present from Rubeus Hagrid’s period because Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It is created from the show one Hagrid got that status in this many years out-of his expulsion off college during the 1942. In you to scene off Harry Potter and Cup regarding Flame, Molly Weasley reminisces on Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper seem to convergence which have Molly’s many years in school, it appears to be unlikely you to she remembers a past gamekeeper. Although not, you’ll be able to one Hagrid did not be a great gamekeeper immediately immediately following becoming expelled, but instead already been given that Ogg’s assistant. It is plausible because when Harry believes he often become expelled to have flying with the broomstick versus permission in his first 12 months, he secret in the event that however be allowed to stay on just like the Hagrid’s assistant.
Schreibe einen Kommentar